What Will Happen to the Juvenile in the December 16 Delhi Gang Rape Case?

If convicted, will he be punished as a juvenile or as an adult? There’s no need to speculate – there are only a few ways this case can go.

The decision of the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB) in the matter involving the juvenile accused in the December 16 Delhi gang rape case will be delivered on Thursday, July 25, 2013. The JJB’s decision will be based on the provisions of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000 (JJ Act) – a law that overrides all other laws on aspects of detention, prosecution, or punishment of juveniles in conflict with the law.

A JJB consists of a principal magistrate and two social workers and conducts inquiries into juvenile crime in a child-friendly, interdisciplinary manner. It focuses not only on whether the child is guilty of the offence or not, but more importantly, on the circumstances of the child at the time and the possible causes that may have triggered it. This facilitates the JJB to pass orders that can address these root causes, reform the juvenile and prevent him or her from falling into a cycle of crime.

The JJB finding this week is expected to be on the point of whether the juvenile was involved in the offences that he's been alleged to have committed. If yes, there are many ways in which he can be dealt with. Under Section 15 of the JJ Act, if the JJB is satisfied that the juvenile has committed an offence it can pass an order and do any of the following:

1.    Advice or admonish him and then allow him to go home after counselling the parents, guardian and the juvenile.

2.    Require him to participate in group counselling and similar activities.

3.    Require him to perform community service.

4.    Order the parent, or the juvenile himself if he earns money and is above 14 years, to pay a fine.

5.    Release him on probation of good conduct and place him under the care of any parent, guardian or other fit person for a maximum period of three years.

6.    Release him on probation of good conduct and place him under the care of any fit institution for a maximum period of three years.

7.    Send him to a ‘Special Home’ (an institution under the Act established to provide special services in order to reform, rehabilitate and re-socialize a juvenile found guilty of a crime) for a period of three years. The Board can take into account the nature of the offence and the circumstances of the case and even reduce the period of stay. It cannot, however, extend the period of stay beyond three years.

What the JJB cannot do is to impose a death sentence or imprisonment for any term, since this is expressly prohibited under the JJ Act as well as under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.

In the event that the juvenile is found to have committed the offences alleged and is ordered to be detained for three years, but has crossed the age of 18 years during the inquiry itself – as is reported in the media about the juvenile in this case – it is possible that the Board could say that he must not be kept in a Special Home with children below the age of 18 years and should instead be detained in a ‘Place of Safety’ owing to his age and seriousness of the offences. A Place of Safety is any place (not a lock-up or a jail) the person in charge of which is willing and able to take responsibility for a juvenile and is found to be fit for the purpose by the JJB.

The juvenile could also be placed in the custody of a ‘Fit Institution’ – a governmental or a registered NGO prepared to own the responsibility of this juvenile and found fit by the State government on recommendation by the JJB to perform this role.

Finally, if he is found to be suffering from any psychiatric disorder or addiction he could be transferred to a psychiatric hospital or Integrated Rehabilitation Centre for Addicts for treatment. 

There could be a combination of orders that the JJB could pass under Section 15, depending on which offences he has been found guilty/innocent of – and he may not be sent to a Special Home or Fit Institution if the JJB is of the view that he does not need to be detained in an institutional setting but be made to serve the orders that are non-institutional in nature.

Under no circumstances, however, can he be housed in a jail.

Before passing the final orders, the JJB will have taken into consideration the findings of the Social Investigation Report prepared by the probation officer or by a recognized voluntary organization on its direction – especially the findings of the circumstances of the crime, the child's background, etc. This final order will also include an Individual Care Plan, again prepared by the probation officer/social organization, which would have recommendations for the services that are required to ensure that the juvenile is reformed and re-integrated back into the community as a law-abiding citizen.

Recent demands for the juvenile in the Delhi gang rape case to be treated as an adult or be sent to an adult prison are untenable in view of the provisions of the Indian Constitution and the JJ Act.

While all human beings, especially growing children, need to be taught that there are consequences for their actions for which they will be held accountable, the means for ensuring such accountability should be grounded in child/adolescent psychology, the human rights of children and an understanding of the circumstances that led to such behavior/actions. 

In 2013, the Supreme Court considered several petitions challenging the constitutional validity of provisions of the JJA, particularly the need to reconsider the definition of a juvenile in conflict with law in light of the Delhi gang rape case. On July 17, 2013, the Supreme Court dismissed the petitions and upheld the validity of the provisions of the JJ Act on the basis of the rich jurisprudence of child rights, international standards and the scientific basis of the JJ Act.

The court noted that while debating the JJ Act, 2000 the Parliament consciously decided to raise the age of the juvenile from 16 years as it was under previous law, to 18 years and that this represents the “collective wisdom” of Parliament, which the court must not disturb or deviate from.

The demand for revision in law based on the belief of a high rate of juvenile crime is without any foundation. According to the National Crime Records Bureau’s Crime in India-2012, the percentage of IPC crimes committed by juveniles to total IPC crimes reported in the country is a measly 1.2 percent. These numbers point to a modest but vulnerable population that requires to be handled with much more care and caution, so as to prevent recidivism, engineer reform and re-integration, and counter the regressive and outdated idea that children who commit adult crimes, deserve adult time.

The more serious a crime that a juvenile may have committed, the greater is the responsibility of the State to provide reformative services, care and protection to such a person in order to prevent him or her from entering or remaining in a vicious cycle of crime and violence.

Having journeyed with X, a 17-year-old boy who murdered his father, for more than two-and-a-half years, our team at the Centre for Child and the Law, National Law School of India University (CCL NLSIU) is convinced that competent authorities providing inter-disciplinary inputs during the legal processes under the JJ Act, and quality services as envisaged in the existing law, are indeed adequate to change the course of a young adolescent's life and keep society safe from juvenile crime.

Our response to juvenile crime has to be fair, age-appropriate and in keeping with developmental psychology – and not a reaction to the countrywide outrage against one juvenile.

The JJ Act is a fairly progressive law grounded in universally recognized principles and approaches. The decision of the JJB on the juvenile allegedly involved in the Delhi gang rape must be viewed from this lens. Emphasis must be laid on effective implementation of the law and sound reformation and rehabilitation programmes.

Our children, our victims of juvenile crime and our society deserve no less.


A Case Study: “I've got my life back”

X was 15 years old when, in a fit of rage, he killed his father who had inflicted violence and shame on the family over many years. X was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder during his eight-and-a-half month stay in an observation home.

The juvenile justice team at the Centre for Child and the Law, NLSIU worked with functionaries, the boy’s family and specialists at a mental health facility to help inform his Individual Care Plan, which was to be part of the final orders by the JJB.

X was ordered to stay in the Special Home for four months, where he was given a strict daily routine that included yoga, computer training and sessions with the specialists.

The team counselor Kalpana Purushothaman continued to provide the emotional support he needed right through his journey in the often terrifying corridors of the juvenile justice system. The advocates, Geeta Sajjanshetty and Shruthi Revankar, not only represented him before the JJB but also worked with his mother in understanding the legal process, given that she was co-accused in the case. The team followed up with X and his family even after his discharge from the Special Home, referring him and his sibling to residential educational institutions, arranging for scholarships, etc.

According to the principal of his college, X seems to have adjusted very well to life in the community and is well on his way to achieving his dream – to become a professional in his field of interest one day.

It is remarkable to see how X now looks straight into your eyes when you speak to him. Those who knew him two years ago now notice that he has a glint in his eye and a slight spring in his awkward adolescent walk as he saunters back into his hostel along with the other young boys his age, a majority of who have faced similar challenges in their young lives.

Arlene Manoharan is a social worker and Research Fellow heading the Juvenile Justice team at Centre for Child and the Law, National Law School of India University (CCL NLSIU). Swagata Raha is a lawyer and consults with CCL NLSIU. For more information see www.nls.ac.in/ccl

Also on Yahoo! Originals

The Hunger Games, Again

India has a third of the world's malnourished children. The Food Security Bill proposes to guarantee basic nutrition even as we hear of children dying everywhere from Kerala to Bihar, from malnutrition to eating poisonous midday meals. Amid the march of grim statistics, Meghala's story is a reminder that the systems are failing our children and they are dying right next to us. Read

Politicians Should Upload Satire Sites, Not Shut Them Down

Amid the Narendra Modi satire flap, a stand-up comic explains why. Read

Surviving rape: The story of Suzette Jordan

What happens to you after rape? What happens to you after the police, the media and your chief minister scorn you? How do you begin to live again? An intimate profile of Suzette Jordan as she finds her way back home. Read

What to do if you have been raped

Despite being warned to expect it all your life, despite all the chatter of the last few months, you probably still don’t know how to deal with sexual assault. A comprehensive look at how Indian women can navigate the first few days after rape. Read on

What’s really going on at the CBI

CBI versus IB. Home Ministry versus CBI. Someone's getting autonomy. And it’s all done with smoke and mirrors. Read on 

Will We Save Nalini Ambady?

The gripping story of Dr Nalini Ambady — honored by Bill Clinton, a collaborator of Malcolm Gladwell — and her battle against a life-threatening illness. Read on

Sheetal Sathe sings of the dark times

In today's police state, it is an "Unlawful Activity" to protest through song and dance and drama. This is one woman's story. It is also Everyone's story

The Secret Life of Mangoes

A juicy celebration of the fruit of kings, the king of fruits
Taksim, Here I Come
What’s really going on at the massive Turkish protests? Tear gas. Water cannons. Batons. Darth Vader police. Penguin cartoons. Free hugs. Slogans in underwear. Our writer found all that and much more.
What is 'natural rape'?
The furor around BJP MP Raghavji is a cue to revise our laws, not to crack crude homophobic jokes, says Kavita Krishnan
The Inscrutable Sex Appeal of Dhanush
If anything was evident post-Kolaveri, it was a lack of knowledge about Dhanush and his work.
How to Sort a Calamity

What does it mean to do relief work in a still-spinning, still-besieged Uttarakhand? Our writer goes to the heart of a major relief operation and discovers its nitty gritties, weirdness and heartbreak

If You’ve Never Worried About A Nuclear Disaster in India, Start Now

The Koodankulam nuclear plant went critical this weekend despite stinging criticism from both pro and anti-nuclear experts. Shouldn’t we terrified that the plant has been dealing with Russian conmen suppliers, missing wiring and electrocution deaths? Shouldn’t we be scared that the nuclear establishment itself admit that they have no disaster management plans?

Dal Will Tell You What the Government Cares About

The proposed Food Security Bill will likely raise the demand for dal across India. While farmers and consumers are against it, the government keeps favouring the agri-industry and importing more and more cheap versions to offset rising inflation. But why won’t India produce its own dal anymore?

Why Are We Ready To Be Eco-Friendly About Everything Except Our Pets?

Why is it that the most fashionably conscious, environment-friendly people have the most inappropriate dogs? Why haven’t they discovered the amazing Indy yet?


  • How to Go From Boyish to ByomkeshWed 25 Mar, 2015

    Sushant Singh Rajput and the man behind the star. And how Dibakar Banerjee moulded him into the beloved everyman detective, Byomkesh Bakshy.

  • What is terrorizing Marathwada’s farmers?Mon 23 Mar, 2015

    The hailstorm and unseasonal rains in 2014 that destroyed the rabi crop were thought to be freak events until they happened again this year, spurring fears of a sharp rise in the number of farmer suicides, bidding to outrun Vidarbha in its tragic scale. Is the weather the sole cause of Marathwada’s agrarian crisis, and how can this crisis be tackled?

  • Can a Counterculture Become an Ethical Industry?Fri 20 Mar, 2015

    These days several Indian cities are enlivened by splashes of color: an imaginative mural, a stylish tag, a critical stencil. Street art and graffiti seem to be sprouting everywhere, but there is growing skepticism in the community on what it means when our consumer culture starts patronizing this usually unsanctioned art form.

  • Is the AAP Crumbling? Again?Wed 18 Mar, 2015

    Despite its incredible win in the Delhi polls, the party’s implosion started a while ago. A look at how all the infighting and backbiting has been steadily coming to a boil.

  • When I Die, I Want A PartyMon 16 Mar, 2015

    In June 2013, the writer met Suzette Jordan a week after she’d decided she would no longer be stifled by the name, ‘The Park Street Rape Victim’ and all that it implied. And there began a quiet friendship. This week, shaken by the news of Jordan’s sudden death, the writer attends the funeral and joins the family in remembering this extraordinary woman.

  • Things I learned at the Asian Women’s FestivalFri 13 Mar, 2015

    The International Association of Women in Radio and Television held its Asian Women’s Film Festival again this year, showcasing the work of women, but not necessarily about women. Here’s what our writer found.

  • Everything you need to know at the legal end of the Masarat Alam controversyTue 10 Mar, 2015

    And what's with Jammu & Kashmir’s Public Safety Act?

  • Is Capital Fever Making Vijayawada Ill?Mon 9 Mar, 2015

    For decades this colorful, swaggering town has dreamt of escape, of leaving, of the US. But now it’s going to be Andhra Pradesh’s capital, and a rush of new money is happily ramming into the old city. There are many with fever dreams for everything ‘World Class’, but does anyone really want to stay in Vijayawada?

  • For the first time in Indian legal history, the Parliament has begun proceedings to attempt to impeach a judge over allegations of sexual harassmentFri 6 Mar, 2015

    Why 58 Rajya Sabha members have signed this petition and everything else you need to know.

  • Why Indian medical research wants you to smile for the cameraWed 4 Mar, 2015

    At the heart of every scandal around drug trials in India has been one question: did the research subject really know what he or she was getting into? For the first time, we might have a clear answer, thanks to a cool new innovation in medical research.

  • Why Do they Protest Being Looted When It’s for their Own Good?Tue 3 Mar, 2015

    In Chhattisgarh’s infamously polluted Korba, Nirupabai came with her aged mother to protest the mine’s expansion that will wipe out her village and put them on the road. In Delhi, Baldiya Rana came with her aged mother to protest the new Land Ordinance that now lets the government grab land without the owner’s consent. Across India, millions are dissenting against the Modi government’s aggressive push to remove checks and balances for acquiring land. The experts on TV say these protestors are ignorant, short-sighted and unaware of the benefits to themselves. But are they?

  • Where do Adivasis stand in Indian law?Fri 27 Feb, 2015

    Adivasis constitute 8.6 percent of Indians. The Constitution has always aimed to protect their interests. Has the law?

  • Siddharth Vihar is gone. And with it, an important piece of Dalit historyWed 25 Feb, 2015

    While the Maharashtra government is going over plans to spend Rs 30 crore to buy the London bungalow that BR Ambedkar once stayed in, Siddharth Vihar, the boys’ hostel in Mumbai that was once the site of important political and cultural activity within the Dalit community, has been demolished. Close to a hundred students have currently been left in the lurch as a result, but here’s why the demolition means so much more.

  • What I Learned by Reading Every Budget Speech Since India got IndependenceMon 23 Feb, 2015

    In 68 years, Budget speeches have provided an idiosyncratic, potted history of the country. And no aspect of the Budget has been more fascinating than that of income tax. From socialist Strict Uncle-style disapproval of high income and a focus on egalitarian ideals to a markedly capitalist approach, here's how income tax has changed over the years.

  • Why Your Car is a Chemistry Lab on WheelsFri 20 Feb, 2015

    What makes cars one of the most successful inventions of all time? The answer lies in science.

  • Which Players Will We Remember from this World Cup?Wed 18 Feb, 2015

    Even in this age of globalized sport, multiple new formats and around-the-clock coverage, the cricket World Cup is unique in how it can transform young players’ performances and reputations. From newcomers to international cricket, like Haris Sohail and Axar Patel to more established young guns like Kane Williamson and Adam Milne, this tournament is already throwing up some fresh faces who are trying to deliver on the promise of a lifetime.

  • The Final Sanjana and Other Truths About the New Horrex HeroineMon 16 Feb, 2015

    Why do horrex heroines in Bollywood rarely get to take charge when it comes to ghostbusting? What should really scare them is a creature that walks on two legs.

  • This Valentine’s Day, should we reserve our love for instant noodles?Fri 13 Feb, 2015

    Is happiness an empty word? Is love only about hormones and neurotransmitters? Our writer ruminates on the confusing urge to send romantic love packing. And why she hasn’t done it yet.

  • Your Sari Is Like A ThermosWed 11 Feb, 2015

    Need the warmth of a sweater in winter and the breeziness of a skirt in summer? A new study finds that the traditional sari is the perfect all-weather clothing – and that everything depends on how you drape it.

  • This is one of India's best psychiatric hospitals. Is it enough?Mon 9 Feb, 2015

    India has about 78 million people with mental health problems, but only one psychiatrist for every 332,226 people, and one psychologist for every 2,127,660 people. Between the vast shortage of treatment options and colonial-style asylums, where does one look for success stories? Our author visits the Schizophrenia Research Foundation (SCARF) in Chennai for a better view.

  • Why Manjunath Kamath Has Returned to His Old and True LoveFri 6 Feb, 2015

    With every new show, Manjunath Kamath promises storytelling, absurdity and wit. As for medium or material, all bets are off since he reinvents his work every time. Leaving behind his digital prints, murals, watercolor animations, claymations and fiber glass sculptures, Kamath has returned to the fragile medium of terracotta sculpture in which he began his journey as a leading artist of his generation.

  • Why is Delhi Looking for a Second Opinion?Thu 5 Feb, 2015

    Here we go again. Delhi is about to elect a new leader amid all the old questions. But this time, the BJP controls both the central government and the municipal corporation. So why are Narendra Modi and his party struggling so much against the perkily resurgent AAP and Arvind Kejriwal? What lode of unpredictability is the capital tapping into?

  • Inside The Fellowship Of The Relentlessly PositiveMon 2 Feb, 2015

    India is said to have the third highest population of HIV positive people in the world. It’s no longer a disease anyone seems to talk about though there are fresh infections everyday. Funds are drying up and everyone’s looking away. But for those newly diagnosed, for those who have been living with it for years, hope comes from within the community. Their fellow sufferers are the ones who fight prejudiced doctors, make sure they stay on the course with drugs, remind them of tomorrow, remind them of love. Across the country, in every district, it is within these tiny rings of hope that the HIV positive find life again.

  • The Questions We Should Be Asking Frequently About the Land Acquisition ActFri 30 Jan, 2015

    And answers from an expert