What Has Gone Wrong at JNU?

In the aftermath of the horrific attack on a student at JNU, a writer on campus explores just what has gone wrong with the university's fabled culture of liberalism and gender sensitivity.


On Sunday night, August 4, the Gender Sensitisation Committee Against Sexual Harassment (GSCASH) at Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) held a public meeting on campus.

It was held to discuss how, a few days before, a student called Roshni was almost fatally axed by her classmate Aakash, following which the attacker 'friend' killed himself by consuming poison. They were both studying at The School of Language, Literature and Culture Studies.

Among the various students who spoke at the meeting was another student from The School of Language who described how she had been assaulted earlier that very day on campus by a former JNU student called Abhinandan Verma. He had apparently developed an unhealthy obsession towards her.

Students immediately helped her file a police complaint and ensure the man was arrested; he has been reportedly barred from the university campus for the next 10 years.

"Anywhere else, the woman would have been questioned first, people would have asked her what she was doing," says Abhiruchi Ranjan, the student representative to the GSCASH. "In JNU, we stood up in solidarity with her."

But many students at this famously liberal university increasingly doubt that narrative of progressiveness.

The plot was drearily familiar: a young man, his advances rejected by a woman, launches a murderous attack on her. But the location wasn't half as familiar: JNU prides itself on being a campus where women can safely walk the streets past midnight - no mean achievement in Delhi.

As news filtered through that a student had hacked a classmate between lectures, the sense of disbelief was palpable. It was the last day of admissions at the university and student activists were shuttling between the administrative block, the hulking sandstone building insiders irreverently call the Pink Palace, and the various schools as they helped new candidates complete their registrations. It was through this relay that the first rumours of the attack seeped into everyone's consciousness.

Fights and fisticuffs are common among the undergraduates of The School of Language, where the attack occurred, and several of the seasoned activists at the admin block presumed it was yet another of one of those. Then more disturbing news came: there was a pistol involved, the woman was lying in a pool of blood in a classroom, the attacker had apparently slit his own throat after the assault.

"My first reaction was a complete blank. How is it possible to be so violent in JNU?" asks B Jenny, a student at The School of Language, who was at the administrative block that muggy morning. "You can imagine it happening in Munirka [a neighbourhood just outside the university], but never in JNU."

Both Roshni, 22, and Aakash, 23, were studying for a BA in Korean at The School of Language. There are both from Bihar. He died soon after taking poison while she remained critical for many days in hospital and is now stable.

In the aftermath of Aakash's assault, there has been much soul searching inside and outside the campus about the loss of its progressive culture. The conversations have been emblematic of a generational shift, as a cohort born after liberalisation and the depoliticisation of the student's movement across the nation, enter the university and are seemingly unaffected by the discourse around them.

JNU's culture was a product of an active student movement that mobilized the campus on issues of gender. Shortly after the Supreme Court ordered institutions in 1997 to take steps to prevent sexual harassment, the students' union agitated for the implementation of that order. The movement led to the formation of the GSCASH at JNU, which was then adopted as a model for universities around the country.

More recently, the JNU students' union sprung up to mobilize students and people outside the campus after the 16 December 2012 Delhi gang rape, which occurred barely a kilometre outside the university. For days on end, JNU students marched with others on the streets of Delhi, braving tear gas and police batons and forcing the government to come up with a tougher law against rape.

Ruchira Sen, who was the-then GSCASH student representative and emerged as a leading face of the December protests, credits these intensely political moments in forging the culture of JNU. But, she fears, there are also scores of students who remain untouched by all the politics.

"What makes JNU safe, what makes it different, is that the public will not tolerate what is patriarchal. JNU people have been changed by the GSCASH movement. That movement has shaped the minds of people. I can't say the movement has died - there was the Nirbhaya [December 16] movement too - but it has not drawn everyone," she says.

Four months after the December protests, a post appeared on the hugely popular JNU Confessions page on Facebook. The writer, claiming to be a student, described how he had persuaded a junior to come to his room and then date-raped her. Whether it was truth, parody or fantasy was never confirmed, but the banal tone of the post and of the responses to it were a worrying sign.

"You have someone bragging that they have raped someone," says Sen. "Even if it didn't happen, there is someone who someone who is propagating rape culture. We're very complacent about our politics. We think because we have a progressive campus we are sanitised of patriarchy. But that's not true. It's not measuring up."

In 2012, the GSCASH was faced with a case where a doctoral candidate attempted to rape a friend in a hostel room. Posters came up demanding swift action. But few of those were by political organisations.

Some saw in this silence an attempt to shield the accused on account of his political and ethnic ties, and later pointed it out as a contrast to the vocal stance the union took during the December 16 protests. The GSCASH recommended that the accused be barred from the campus; the case has gone on appeal to higher authorities, according to a committee person who declined to be named since the proceedings are confidential.

Ranjan, the current student representative of the GSCASH, declined to speak about the specificities of that case. She says that she saw in it, nevertheless, a success story: the system did work, even without fanfare. "You must understand why we decided to remain silent," he says. "What you do when you take out a protest is that you jeopardise the victim's identity. The woman was under a lot of pressure already, she was harassed to withdraw her complaint. That's why the campus political organisations unanimously decided to remain silent."

Ranjan also wouldn't answer questions on the number of cases that have come up to the GSCASH this year, citing rules that prohibit them to be revealed before the annual report is finalised.


A year in JNU costs less than the price of two coffees from the Starbucks outlet just outside campus, and the university's admissions policy works to include students from 'backward regions'. These measures have ensured that a diverse group of candidates are able to find places in JNU every year.

The standard route of socialising newcomers into JNU is through the various political organisations on campus. Membership, sympathy or even curiosity can give you a healthy dose of exposure to debates and meetings, all of which throw students of various backgrounds together. It is these organisations that form the institutional memory of the campus, passing down their culture from one generation to another.

And yet, there are people who fall between the cracks. JNU can be a confusing place for a large section of students, unaccustomed to the responsibilities that the liberal environment requires to maintain itself. Without that socialisation, the diversity can become a stage for wrong messages to be read in another's actions. As probably Aakash did, when he felt that his assault was justified for what he felt was Roshni's 'betrayal' of his affections.

"Because we do the same kind of politics that is done everywhere, it works like politics everywhere," says Sen. "A small elite group is the most vocal. People judge JNU and its politics by them. But politics and JNU is not only Lenin Kumar [JNU union president], it is also Aakash. People like Aakash are the underbelly of JNU."

This 'underbelly' is strikingly observable each time 16 of the hostels host their cultural nights. Across three months or so in the beginning of the year, student committees in hostels plan nights with names like 'Stellanti Nocte', events that many on campus argue serve to connect diverse people in an informal setting.
An activist who didn't want to be named describes the evening as venues free of the political correctness that characterises JNU's public spaces, where people can have "mindless fun." He seems to see them as an occasion where students can shed the burden of having to conform to JNU's formal discourse.

The biggest draws at these hostel nights are the Bollywood item numbers that students perform. Accompanying these dances are catcalls and hoots from men, emboldened by the darkness, the crowds and the anonymity.

To others, though, these events are only the most visible manifestations of a broader malaise. "The hostel nights aren't the only places where these incidents occur," says Anagha Ingole, a student of international relations. "It happens at the dhabas and around the campus. It's always there. What happens is that in hostel nights it becomes very visible."

Ingole, who contested the student union vice-president's post two years ago, points to the manner in which activists approach the problem. "Our gender discourse is very patronising. We just rule out certain kinds of people. To an extent we are elite," she says. "It is all about what women's rights are. There is no attempt to engage with men and masculinities. Men feel very alienated from the GSCASH. After the GSCASH movement (of the 1990s), we have been unable to catch up with the concerns of a new generation."

The men Ingole mentioned include those on whose faces embarrassment is palpable when, early morning, they run into a woman in the men's washroom. It is not uncommon and not against regulations for women to stay over in men's rooms overnight (but men are not allowed to enter women's hostels). Little has been done by organisations to reach out to men uncomfortable with the idea of sharing spaces with women.

A male student who did not want to be named spoke of his first days on campus. "For me, coming from a village, this was the first time I interacted with female classmates. It took time to adjust to that. Even now, I feel that JNU is skewed towards women and that men are overlooked."

There are also the men who haven't engaged with women or ideas of gender justice. For many, the GSCASH is little more than an administrative body for women; as the former GSCASH representative Ruchira Sen herself put it, it seems "a complaints redressal body rather than a body responsible to the student community."

"[Last week's murderous attack] may have been an exception," says Chandrabhan, a student of history. "But these mentalities exist. People come with their baggage and you can't expect them to change overnight, or even in a year."

This divide is not one of elite versus subaltern, as some have attempted to brand by pinning the blame for his attack on Aakash's rural upbringing or the culture of his home state Bihar.

As Aashique Iqbal, a history student, points out, "We must recognise the constraints of JNU's 'exceptionalism'. We're living this life on the vestiges of a past revolution and not because of any present movement. Our gender discourse is still stuck in the 1970s. We must understand that gender problems are not always sexual; but in JNU there is a tendency to sexualise them, as if everything can be explained as a result of misdirected male frustration."

There is a growing realisation that the university's culture and politics have done little to engage with those on campus who have been left behind. At the heart of the matter lies the challenge of forging a new gender discourse on campus, one that engages equally with the anxieties of feminism and masculinities.

Aakash's suicide note talked about his hurt ego after what he perceived as Roshni's indifference towards him - and as the implications of this emerge in our political discussions, there is a need to bring in men to talk about themselves and their relationships.

"There is a cultural gap. People come with certain ideas about caste, about women. Some people change. Then there are people who never change, who will never engage with anything," says B Jenny, the languages student. "It's not enough to say they are people who have old fashioned thoughts. It's time to make them talk about why they think that way. The question is: How are we going to make them feel that they are part of this community and that they have a responsibility to make this a safe place?"

CJ Kuncheria is a research scholar at the Centre for Historical Studies at Jawaharlal Nehru University. He was formerly a New Delhi-based correspondent for an international news agency.

Also on Yahoo! Originals

Delhi rape: What’ll happen to the juvenile?

If convicted in the December 16 Delhi gang-rape case, will he be punished as a juvenile or as an adult? More
The Hunger Games, Again
India has a third of the world's malnourished children. The Food Security Bill proposes to guarantee basic nutrition even as we hear of children dying everywhere from Kerala to Bihar, from malnutrition to eating poisonous midday meals. Amid the march of grim statistics, Meghala's story is a reminder that the systems are failing our children and they are dying right next to us. Read

Politicians Should Upload Satire Sites, Not Shut Them Down

Amid the Narendra Modi satire flap, a stand-up comic explains why. Read

Surviving rape: The story of Suzette Jordan

What happens to you after rape? What happens to you after the police, the media and your chief minister scorn you? How do you begin to live again? An intimate profile of Suzette Jordan as she finds her way back home. Read

What to do if you have been raped

Despite being warned to expect it all your life, despite all the chatter of the last few months, you probably still don’t know how to deal with sexual assault. A comprehensive look at how Indian women can navigate the first few days after rape. Read on

What’s really going on at the CBI

CBI versus IB. Home Ministry versus CBI. Someone's getting autonomy. And it’s all done with smoke and mirrors. Read on

ALSO ON YAHOO ORIGINALS

  • Siddharth Vihar is gone. And with it, an important piece of Dalit historyWed 25 Feb, 2015

    While the Maharashtra government is going over plans to spend Rs 30 crore to buy the London bungalow that BR Ambedkar once stayed in, Siddharth Vihar, the boys’ hostel in Mumbai that was once the site of important political and cultural activity within the Dalit community, has been demolished. Close to a hundred students have currently been left in the lurch as a result, but here’s why the demolition means so much more.

  • What I Learned by Reading Every Budget Speech Since India got IndependenceMon 23 Feb, 2015

    In 68 years, Budget speeches have provided an idiosyncratic, potted history of the country. And no aspect of the Budget has been more fascinating than that of income tax. From socialist Strict Uncle-style disapproval of high income and a focus on egalitarian ideals to a markedly capitalist approach, here's how income tax has changed over the years.

  • Why Your Car is a Chemistry Lab on WheelsFri 20 Feb, 2015

    What makes cars one of the most successful inventions of all time? The answer lies in science.

  • Which Players Will We Remember from this World Cup?Wed 18 Feb, 2015

    Even in this age of globalized sport, multiple new formats and around-the-clock coverage, the cricket World Cup is unique in how it can transform young players’ performances and reputations. From newcomers to international cricket, like Haris Sohail and Axar Patel to more established young guns like Kane Williamson and Adam Milne, this tournament is already throwing up some fresh faces who are trying to deliver on the promise of a lifetime.

  • The Final Sanjana and Other Truths About the New Horrex HeroineMon 16 Feb, 2015

    Why do horrex heroines in Bollywood rarely get to take charge when it comes to ghostbusting? What should really scare them is a creature that walks on two legs.

  • This Valentine’s Day, should we reserve our love for instant noodles?Fri 13 Feb, 2015

    Is happiness an empty word? Is love only about hormones and neurotransmitters? Our writer ruminates on the confusing urge to send romantic love packing. And why she hasn’t done it yet.

  • Your Sari Is Like A ThermosWed 11 Feb, 2015

    Need the warmth of a sweater in winter and the breeziness of a skirt in summer? A new study finds that the traditional sari is the perfect all-weather clothing – and that everything depends on how you drape it.

  • This is one of India's best psychiatric hospitals. Is it enough?Mon 9 Feb, 2015

    India has about 78 million people with mental health problems, but only one psychiatrist for every 332,226 people, and one psychologist for every 2,127,660 people. Between the vast shortage of treatment options and colonial-style asylums, where does one look for success stories? Our author visits the Schizophrenia Research Foundation (SCARF) in Chennai for a better view.

  • Why Manjunath Kamath Has Returned to His Old and True LoveFri 6 Feb, 2015

    With every new show, Manjunath Kamath promises storytelling, absurdity and wit. As for medium or material, all bets are off since he reinvents his work every time. Leaving behind his digital prints, murals, watercolor animations, claymations and fiber glass sculptures, Kamath has returned to the fragile medium of terracotta sculpture in which he began his journey as a leading artist of his generation.

  • Why is Delhi Looking for a Second Opinion?Thu 5 Feb, 2015

    Here we go again. Delhi is about to elect a new leader amid all the old questions. But this time, the BJP controls both the central government and the municipal corporation. So why are Narendra Modi and his party struggling so much against the perkily resurgent AAP and Arvind Kejriwal? What lode of unpredictability is the capital tapping into?

  • Inside The Fellowship Of The Relentlessly PositiveMon 2 Feb, 2015

    India is said to have the third highest population of HIV positive people in the world. It’s no longer a disease anyone seems to talk about though there are fresh infections everyday. Funds are drying up and everyone’s looking away. But for those newly diagnosed, for those who have been living with it for years, hope comes from within the community. Their fellow sufferers are the ones who fight prejudiced doctors, make sure they stay on the course with drugs, remind them of tomorrow, remind them of love. Across the country, in every district, it is within these tiny rings of hope that the HIV positive find life again.

  • The Questions We Should Be Asking Frequently About the Land Acquisition ActFri 30 Jan, 2015

    And answers from an expert

  • His Were the StreetsThu 29 Jan, 2015

    What’s written on our walls is important because sometimes our death warrants first appear there. Mohammed Hanif remembers his friend Asim Butt, an artist whose wall art seemed to have found a way of marrying JG Ballard to Habib Jalib. From hubcap lice to the backs of trucks, from Eject signs during Musharraf ’s emergency to the mythical perfume chowk, Hanif meanders through Karachi indulging his special fondness for the writing on walls.

  • America’s Chanting Guru and His Swaying Indian TourTue 27 Jan, 2015

    He’s supposed to be the bestselling chant artist of all time. He performed at the 2013 Grammy awards. Almost 45 years after he first came here, Krishna Das is conducting his first ticketed tour of public kirtans across India and minting some rather unusual fans of Hanuman chanting. Is it all really a spiritual hit back from the West or a long-awaited cashing in?

  • Nothing to See Here. Move Along. Just The Uncle-ification of Urdu in IndiaWed 21 Jan, 2015

    What else can explain its current he-he-joking, controversy-fearing, good-job loving avatar?

  • No historians were hurt in the making of this objectMon 19 Jan, 2015

    The 75th Indian History Congress this month should have been the site of another skirmish in the ongoing culture and memory wars. And the Congress waited with bated breath, convinced there'd be bloodshed.

  • Who Will Stop The Plagiarists?Sat 17 Jan, 2015

    In the drawing room of a suburban West Delhi home sits an elderly vigilante, the head of an organization that has been tracking criminal vice-chancellors, unethical professors and copycat students since 1981. But with only the force of moral authority to help them battle plagiarism in India's scientific community, can the Society for Scientific Values keep up the good fight?

  • If you're in your second trimester and want to get an abortion in Maharashtra, good luckWed 14 Jan, 2015

    The laws in Maharashtra are pitting those who fight against sex selection and those who fight for abortion rights against each other. Meanwhile it's not fun times for women.

  • When parents pay for international schools what do they think they are getting?Mon 12 Jan, 2015

    And is it paisa vasool?

  • Why are we pretending that there isn’t a growing mountain of menstrual waste we need to deal with?Fri 9 Jan, 2015

    And no, burning them is not the best idea ever.

  • Love may know no locksmiths but teenage lovers in India can now be stuck with rape chargesWed 7 Jan, 2015

    The well-meaning new laws were meant to protect children from adult predators. So why are they now criminalizing underage consensual sex? And how did they become the handy tool of angry parents?

  • What Makes Virat Kohli So Brash, Flash and Eager to Smash?Mon 5 Jan, 2015

    He likes the cameras, he likes his hero status and he likes to play hard. India's new cricket captain is incredibly different from his revered predecessors in his win-and-enjoy-at-all-costs gusto. Is this the beginning of the age of Kohli?

  • Yahoo Originals: The Best of 2014Wed 24 Dec, 2014

    The heaviest, coolest and craziest stories of the year. From Kabul to Chennai, from Kashmir to the Andamans, from Manipur to Jharkhand, our writers went everywhere. And found everything that shook us this year: sex, politics, doughnuts, football, gods, deserts, seas and much more.

  • Why I Like Leaning In. Way In. Into My All-Girls’ HostelTue 9 Dec, 2014

    Is a women’s hostel a utopia or dystopia, or is it even better – a place to ignore the boring universe of men? Our writer reluctantly joined a hostel, only to fall in love with the wheels within wheels, the worlds within worlds she found – a sakhi sammelan, Renaissance Florence, a sandcastle and a place to play academic Thelma & Louise.