Historian Romila Thapar’s name is the subject of a controversy yet again. This time around, a clip of the academic allegedly claiming that Yudhisthira, of the epic Mahabharata, was inspired by ‘Ashoka’ is trending on social media.
A one minute extract from a hour-long video has been doing the rounds on Twitter since Saturday, 21 September, with many questioning the historian’s credentials.
Pointing out the disparity in the timeline of the two events, several social media users took this opportunity to mock and criticise JNU’s professor emeritus.
However, there were some who came to her support and pointed out that the ‘Yudhisthira’ she mentioned was not the mythological figure, but rather the written character in the epic.
Citing the clip, a member of the ‘Art of Living’ organisation questioned Thapar’s knowledge.
Mahabharata war happened around 3137 BC and King Ashoka’s time is 304 to 232 BCE, but, historian (?) #RomilaThapar feels that Yudhishitira got this idea about renunciation from Ashoka! ( @Bharathgyan @sgurumurthy @madhukishwar @davidfrawleyved @rvaidya2000 @TVMohandasPai ) pic.twitter.com/lmViP1OxHX— Swamiji (@AOLSwamiji) September 21, 2019
Many right-wing Twitter personalities, with ‘Hyper Nationalist’ or ‘Right-winger’ in their bios, were voraciously tweeting and criticising the professor’s ‘mistake’.
Ashoka :- 268-232 BCE.— Archie (@archu243) September 21, 2019
Yudhishthira :- 3500-4000 BCE
But yet Ashoka inspired Yudhishthira as per #RomilaThapar
This is how gross distortion of facts is fed to the younger generations as History by such eminent “HISTORIANS”#SaturdayThoughtspic.twitter.com/OoKWdO8DHr
There were also some who chose to react with humour and sarcasm.
I heard Valmiki wrote the screenplay for The Avengers. Can you please confirm #RomilaThapar? Sources say the story broke from your stable. ??— Vin Sinners (@vinsinners) September 21, 2019
#YoSonakshiSoDumb ṭrending due to (lack of info about) Ramayana & #RomilaThapar trending due to (her own made up version of) Mahabharata !!— Shehzad Jai Hind (@Shehzad_Ind) September 21, 2019
And here I thought Ramayana & Mahabharata is known to every Indian irrespective of his or her religion!!
What Did She Say in the Video
Soon after the clipping went viral, the full video of Thapar’s talk surfaced online. The video, posted on Youtube in 2010, is titled ‘Romila Thapar - India's Past and Present: How History Informs Contemporary Narrative.’
In the video, she’s seen conversing with IDRC President David M Malone. Here is the full video:
In the full version of the speech, Thapar is seen speaking about the changing perception of Ashoka and Buddhist ideas.
Thapar raises the point that in Buddhist texts, Ashoka is celebrated as an emblem of peace, non-violence and tolerance. The figure was then later picked up by Nehru and turned into an emblem of ‘New India’. However, in Brahmanical texts, he is listed merely as a Mauryan ruler.
She then point out how, contrary to popular belief, some historians in the recent past have been arguing for the presence of Buddhist ideas in epics. Thapar then highlights Yudhisthira’s struggle in Shanti Parva, the twelfth of eighteen books of the Indian Epic Mahabharata.
Sharing a struggle common with Ashoka’s, ‘Yudhisthira’ has to pick between kingship and renunciation. This, Thapar points out, can be traced to the Buddhist idea of power vs renunciation.
In Her Support
While many on Twitter slammed Thapar, several users came out in support of her views.
Popular historian and mythology expert Devdutt Pattanaik tweeted to clarify the time periods of the two texts that Thapar highlights. A supporter of parallel narratives, Pattanaik’s work on Mahabharata, Jaya, is widely read and celebrated.
Pattanaik clarified that Thapar refers to Yudhisthira, the character in an epic composed 2000 years ago and Ashoka who ‘wrote edicts’ 2300 years ago.
She is referring to Yudhisthira as a ‘character in an epic’ composed 2000 years ago who is traumatised by war. With a historical figure Ashoka who ‘wrote edicts’ 2300 years ago proclaiming his remorse. Chill https://t.co/weVkbEq4mT— Devdutt Pattanaik (@devduttmyth) September 21, 2019
In the beginning of September, JNU administration had received flak from academic circles and media as the University had asked Thapar to submit her CV for ‘assessment’.
Thapar holds the position of Professor emeritus in the history department of the University. Several professors were taken aback by this action as the emiratus post is usually designated for life. Thapar, who taught at JNU between 1970 and 1991, was appointed to the post in 1993.
The Jawaharlal Nehru University Teachers’ Association had called the move “politically motivated.”
Others called out the University’s demand a step to “dishonour the acclaimed historian”, who has been critical of changes in the JNU and for not ascribing to the right-wing narration of ancient history.
In the past, her works have been criticised by the Right for perpetuating a plural history of the nation.
In reply to the demand, Thapar had submitted a letter to the administration explaining the status of her position, and had refused to submit her CV.
. Read more on News by The Quint.RSS & BJP’s Nehru-Netaji ‘Cosplay’: Irony Dies a Thousand DeathsRomila Thapar’s ‘Ashoka-Yudhisthira’ Reference Sparks Controversy . Read more on News by The Quint.