The I’m A Celebrity runner-up, who showcased her impressions of the islanders on the show, was put to the test after she was challenged to convince Fincham she was Dyer.
Calling the former pen salesman live on Capital Breakfast, Atack started off strong with a thick accent that perfectly mimicked Dyer.
“Hello babe you alright? It’s me,” she said.
A confused Fincham asked: “Who’s that? Who’s that?”
Atack was then forced to confirm: “It’s me Dani! I’m calling from another number.”
Things then went south quickly with Fincham revealing: “She’s standing in front of me! You’ve ruined it. She’s standing in the kitchen making me something to eat. You know what though, I’ll be honest, if she wasn’t here I probably would’ve believed it.”
Emily Atack does amazing Love Island impressions
Atack was left in hysterics on realising the prank had completely failed.
Putting the Inbetweeners star to the ultimate test, she then attempted to mimic Dyer while on the phone to her.
A shocked Dyer confirmed: “Oh my god that sounds like me! That actually sounds like me. I sound horrible!”
Atack mocked: “So that went well. You weren’t supposed to be standing in front of Jack. I was supposed to prank Jack that so didn’t work.”
Dyer apologised for messing up Atack’s prank, chuckling over the coincidental fail.
She was joined by Extra Camp hosts Scarlett Moffatt and Joel Dommett for a night on the town after revealing to A-list how she is a reformed character thanks to her stint in the jungle.
Tune in to Capital on FM, DAB digital radio, on mobile via the Capital app and Global Player and online at capitalfm.com or ask your smart speaker to “play Capital.”