Centre, Tamil Nadu govt oppose Rajiv Gandhi case convict Nalini''s plea to be set free

Chennai: The Centre has reaffirmed in the Madras High Court its stand that the Rajiv Gandhi assassination case convicts cannot be set free without its consent and said the Tamil Nadu cabinet recommendation for their premature release would have 'zero' effect.

The oral submission was made on Thursday by Additional Solicitor General (ASG) G Rajagopalan before a bench of Justices R Subbiah and R Pongiappan during the hearing of a petition by Nalini, one of the seven life convicts, seeking to declare her detention as illegal.

Nalini has moved the court contending that since the Tamil Nadu Governor had failed to order her release based on the September 9, 2018 recommendation of the state cabinet, she was in illegal detention.

Also Read: Rajiv Gandhi assassination case convict Nalini Sriharan goes on hunger strike demanding release

The bench, which heard arguments from all parties, reserved its orders on her petition.

Opposing the plea of Nalini, the ASG cited a Supreme Court order and said unless there was an order in the name of the Governor, it was not an illegal detention.

He said the resolution passed by the state Council of Ministers was not an order (for release).

Referring to an earlier litigation by Nalini in the Supreme Court, he said then the question raised was whether the state government has the power to release the convicts without the consent or consultation of the Central government under CrPC provisions.

The apex court had held that the Centre's consent or concurrence was necessary because the case was investigated by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Rajagopalan said.

Already the central government had refused to release these convicts. Besides, as per the Supreme Court orders, life sentence means imprisonment till death, he said.

Intervening, the bench asked the ASG then what will be the effect of the state cabinet's decision recommending premature release of the seven convicts (under Article 161 of the Constitution), which is pending before the Governor.

To this, the the Centre's counsel said the effect of the resolution passed by the cabinet was Zero.

In its counter affidavit filed earlier this month, the Centre had said the Tamil Nadu Governor has the discretion under powers conferred by the Constitution, to decide on the pending mercy petition of Perarivalan, another life convict in the case.

State Public Prosecutor A Natarajan, in his arguments on Thursday submitted that some of the offences committed by the accused come under the Central Act and therefore, for the purpose of commutation or remission, the state government has to get consent from the central government.

The Cabinet passed a resolution requesting the Governor to release all the seven convicts. It can only recommend or request the Governor to consider their release and cannot demand or ask him to set them free, he said adding it was for the Governor to decide.

Unless an order was passed, there was no question of illegal detention of Nalini, he added. Radhakrishnan, counsel for Nalini, contended the resolution passed by the Council of Ministers was binding on the governor.

Since the cabinet advised the Governor on September 9, 2018 to release the petitioner, the order to the effect should have been issued the very next day itself by the government, he maintained.

As per the ruling of the Supreme Court in Maru Rams case, the Governor's signature was not necessary for the purpose of releasing the petitioner, he claimed.

All the seven were convicted by a special TADA court for their role in the assassination of former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi on May 21, 1991 by an LTTE suicide bomber during an election rally at nearby Sriperumbudur.

They were sentenced to death, but later it was commuted to life imprisonment.

Besides Nalini, the other life convicts are her husband Murugan, A G Perarivalan, Santhan, Jayakumar, Ravichandran and Robert Pyas.

  • Coronavirus and Sex: What You Should Know About Intimacy During The Covid-19 Pandemic
    News
    News18

    Coronavirus and Sex: What You Should Know About Intimacy During The Covid-19 Pandemic

    What are the risks associated with sex in the time of coronavirus? An experts answers all questions and gives some do's and don'ts.

  • After Radhe, Bigg Boss 13 Winner Sidharth Shukla Has Bagged Another Bollywood Movie?
    News
    News18

    After Radhe, Bigg Boss 13 Winner Sidharth Shukla Has Bagged Another Bollywood Movie?

    Sidharth Shukla, the Bigg Boss 13 winner, said he is looking forward to restart work on his projects soon. Earlier, he signed Radhe-Your Most Wanted Bhai.

  • COVID-19 & Tablighi Markaz: Religions Must Protect, Not Endanger
    News
    The Quint

    COVID-19 & Tablighi Markaz: Religions Must Protect, Not Endanger

    The primary duty of religion—at least its chief promise—is to protect the devout.

  • The Coronavirus Lockdown Has Cricketers Cooking, Cleaning – And Also Working Out
    News
    HuffPost India

    The Coronavirus Lockdown Has Cricketers Cooking, Cleaning – And Also Working Out

    Cricketers across the world are home as the Indian Premier League (IPL) 2020is postponed and India is under a lockdown to contain the COVID-19 outbreak.

  • 'Wonderful': Ivanka Trump Thanks PM Modi for 'Yoga Nidra' Tip during Coronavirus Lockdown
    News
    News18

    'Wonderful': Ivanka Trump Thanks PM Modi for 'Yoga Nidra' Tip during Coronavirus Lockdown

    Ivanka, who had recently visited India along with her husband Jared Kushner, Melania and Donald Trump on his maiden visit to the country earlier in the year, thanked Modi for sharing the videos.

  • Horoscope Today, April 1, 2020: Aries, Pisces, Leo, Cancer, and other signs – check astrological prediction
    News
    The Indian Express

    Horoscope Today, April 1, 2020: Aries, Pisces, Leo, Cancer, and other signs – check astrological prediction

    Aquarius, The principle group of planets now affords you a marvellous opportunity to have your cake and eat it, probably several times over!

  • At Kerala hospital, an outpouring of love as five test negative and return home
    News
    The Indian Express

    At Kerala hospital, an outpouring of love as five test negative and return home

    A 25-year-old man, his parents aged 55 and 53, and two of their relatives were allowed to leave the isolation ward at the general hospital after their swab samples tested negative twice for coronavirus. The permission was in keeping with the World Health Organisation protocol.

  • Don’t Give ‘Garbage Response’:  Pietersen Roasts Ahmed Shehzad
    News
    The Quint

    Don’t Give ‘Garbage Response’: Pietersen Roasts Ahmed Shehzad

    Kevin Pietersen roasted Pakistan batsman Ahmed Shahzad on his Instagram live.

  • New York Governor Andrew Cuomo Would be a Better Candidate Than Biden, Says Donald Trump
    News
    News18

    New York Governor Andrew Cuomo Would be a Better Candidate Than Biden, Says Donald Trump

    Cuomo is not in the running in the Democratic primaries, but his handling of the crisis in New York, the epicenter of the coronavirus pandemic in the United States with some 60,000 reported cases, had seen his approval rating skyrocket from 41 percent in February to 71 percent.

  • Scared and Scarred: Covid-19 Lockdown Taking a Physical & Psychological Toll on India's Street Children
    News
    News18

    Scared and Scarred: Covid-19 Lockdown Taking a Physical & Psychological Toll on India's Street Children

    A daily news video series on YouTube by a group of young reporters living in urban slums underscores the fresh challenges being faced by the already vulnerable homeless children.

  • Made Rotis For All, Now None Left for Me: Hunger at Delhi Shelter
    News
    The Quint

    Made Rotis For All, Now None Left for Me: Hunger at Delhi Shelter

    Hunger reigns in Delhi’s night shelters as many daily wage workers and homeless people go there in hope of food.

  • As Maharashtra denies community transmission, sporadic cases spike
    News
    The Indian Express

    As Maharashtra denies community transmission, sporadic cases spike

    Officially, while the government has strongly denied any indication of community transmission, experts said these cases are ringing alarm bells that the virus is silently making its way into the community.

  • Amruta Khanvilkar Donates Rs 1 Lakh To Maharashtra CM Fund In Fight Against COVID-19
    News
    News18

    Amruta Khanvilkar Donates Rs 1 Lakh To Maharashtra CM Fund In Fight Against COVID-19

    The Malang actress shared the news of her contribution on Instagram, and urged others to donate as much as they can, for the Coronavirus pandemic.

  • Astronauts Can Use Their Own Urine to Build Bases on the Moon
    News
    News18

    Astronauts Can Use Their Own Urine to Build Bases on the Moon

    Transporting about 0.45 kg from the Earth to space costs about $10,000, that means that building a complete module on our satellite in this way would be very expensive.

  • COVID-19 Karnataka wrap: Man under home quarantine commits suicide
    News
    The Indian Express

    COVID-19 Karnataka wrap: Man under home quarantine commits suicide

    The man had returned from Mumbai to his native village at Shravanabelagola for the Ugadi festival.

  • WWE Monday Night Raw results and recap: March 30, 2020
    News
    myKhel

    WWE Monday Night Raw results and recap: March 30, 2020

    Bengaluru, March 31: A star-studded night was in-store for WWE Monday Night Raw on the occasion of the go-home show for Wrestlemania 36 as marquee names like Brock Lesnar, The Undertaker, Edge and more were in attendance to add hype

  • Explained: How does alcohol in sanitisers (and soap) kill the coronavirus?
    News
    The Indian Express

    Explained: How does alcohol in sanitisers (and soap) kill the coronavirus?

    Handwashing for 20 seconds at least kills the virus. When using a sanitiser, it should ideally have an alcohol content of 60% or more.

  • Coronavirus Epidemic Far from Over in Asia, Prepare for Large-Scale Community Transmission: WHO
    News
    News18

    Coronavirus Epidemic Far from Over in Asia, Prepare for Large-Scale Community Transmission: WHO

    The WHO has warned that countries seeing a tapering off of cases should not let down their guard, or the virus may come surging back.

  • Bigg Boss 13's Devoleena Bhattacharjee Sad About People Not Taking Lockdown Seriously
    News
    News18

    Bigg Boss 13's Devoleena Bhattacharjee Sad About People Not Taking Lockdown Seriously

    Devoleena Bhattacharjee expressed her shock on the incident of mass exodus of migrants from Delhi, and had a strong message for rule breakers.

  • Gujarat: Trains to transport food, medicines from Mar 31
    News
    The Indian Express

    Gujarat: Trains to transport food, medicines from Mar 31

    According officials, the two parcel trains can be run by private parties by "registering their indent" at zonal-level offices in order to transport essential goods such as milk, food items, spices and food commodities, medicines and medical equipment.

  • News
    ANI

    Government lowers interest rates on PPF, Sukanya, Senior Citizen, other small saving schemes

    New Delhi [India], Mar 31 (ANI): Facing economic challenges due to threat posed by coronavirus, the government on Tuesday lowered the rates of interest on various small savings schemes including Public Provident Fund, Sukanya Samriddhi and Kisan Vikas Patra for the first quarter of the financial year 2020-21 starting from April 1. For Kisan Kisan Vikas Patra it has been reduced from 7.6 per cent to 6.9 per cent. The KVP will mature in 124 months instead of 113 months earlier. The rate of interest for the Senior Citizen Savings Scheme has been reduced to 7.4 from 8.6 per cent. For the monthly income scheme, it comes down to 6.6 per cent from 7.6 per cent. For five-year recurring deposit, the interest has been reduced from 7.2 to 5.8 per cent. For five year time-deposit, it has been brought down from 7.7 per cent to 6.7 per cent and from 6.9 to 5.5 per cent for three-years, two-years and one-year time deposits.

  • 'There are food shortages': thousands of Australians stuck abroad amid coronavirus plead for help to get home
    News
    The Guardian

    'There are food shortages': thousands of Australians stuck abroad amid coronavirus plead for help to get home

    Citizens overseas from India to Peru and on cruise ships fear window to return to Australia is rapidly shutting * Sign up for Guardian Australia’s daily coronavirus email * Follow live global coronavirus updates * See all our coronavirus coverageAlmost 300 Australians have landed in Sydney on a commercial repatriation flight from South America, but thousands of citizens and permanent residents still remain stranded across the world as airlines cease flying and more national borders lock down.Many still stranded have been caught by desperate family circumstance, suddenly cancelled flights or closed borders and fear the window to return home is rapidly closing without definitive action from the Australian government to repatriate its citizens.They have begged for the government to launch repatriation flights, as other countries have, to rescue them. Trapped in India’s lockdownHundreds of Australians have been stranded in the world’s largest lockdown, imposed by the Indian prime minister, Narendra Modi, on the country’s 1.3 billion people.Vipul, an Australian permanent resident who was waiting on his citizenship ceremony, cannot return home to his wife and two-year-old son in Melbourne.He had come to Navsari, in the western Indian state of Gujarat, to see his brother, who was critically ill with cancer. His return flight to Australia was cancelled and the imposition of a martially enforced lockdown of all of India has left him unable to find a way home.“I am desperate to see my wife and son, who are alone in Australia in this pandemic situation,” he said. “Please help me out to fly to Melbourne as soon as possible.”Internal travel in India is also heavily restricted. Modi, formerly the chief minister of Gujarat state, told the country’s population: “Forget what going out means.”Vipul told the Guardian: “I would also have to go by road from Navsari in Gujarat to Mumbai to catch the flight. It is 400km by road to Mumbai from where I am now.”Max Larkin, a student from Western Australia, said police in Rishikesh, in the foothills of the Himalayas, were strictly and at times violently enforcing the lockdown. No one was allowed out, except for three hours in the morning when essential shops – food markets and pharmacies – were open between 7am and 10am.“There are shortages in food by the end of the morning because it’s chaos,” Larkin said. “The policy of only three hours is mental because overcrowding happens and people fight over food. The chance of spreading disease is much higher.”India has a relatively low number of Covid-19 cases, with 1,024 infections and 95 deaths. But most states have recorded cases and there are widespread concerns the true number of infections could be significantly higher because testing is not widespread.“There is undeniable poverty and many people ... don’t have access to healthcare,” Larkin said. “The beds will fill up in no time; 1.3 billion people is hard to manage at the best of times. Our government can’t even manage 28 million. They are talking about using hydroxychloroquine, which is an anti-malarial drug with awful side effects.“Another aspect that should be considered is the fact that a majority of Indians are daily wage-earners … if they aren’t allowed out, they will starve. I am not sure how long they will stay at home for a virus if faced with starvation. We are kind of scared of the chance of riots if people are forced to stay home without economic help from the government.”Larkin stressed that he was safe and well, but dispirited watching other foreign nationals being repatriated by their governments while Australians remained stranded, facing an unknown future. Citizens of the Czech Republic, France, Germany and other European countries as well the US, Canada and Israel have been repatriated on government run-flights.“I don’t know what to do, and it really comes down to uncertainty,” he said. “We need to know what’s going to happen and what we must do and the only way that can happen is if there is a genuine effort by the Australian government to act in the best interests of all its citizens, even the ones overseas.“I know the government has a lot going on at the home front, but surely there is a branch in it somewhere that can get us home safely.”Australia’s high commission in New Delhi has told citizens to stay indoors and avoid “any crowded place”.“If your situation is or becomes life-threatening, or you have serious concerns for your welfare – for example, cannot find any accommodation whatsoever, or any food, or essential medications – please don’t hesitate to contact us,” consular officials have said.While stressing there were no plans for “assisted departures” for Australian citizens, “the government has agreed to consider, on a case-by-case basis, supporting Australian airlines to operate non-scheduled services to less central locations to bring Australians home”. Flight from Peru oversubscribedEarly Tuesday morning, Sydney time, 292 Australian citizens and permanent residents landed in Sydney from Peru on a commercial charter flight organised by the tour company Chimu Adventures with Australian government assistance.The oversubscribed flight took off from Lima’s military airport on Monday morning, Australia time, also carrying passengers flown from Cusco. The flight flew to Santiago, Chile, where, after a stopover of several hours, passengers boarded another aircraft bound for Sydney. All passengers were tested for Covid-19 before boarding – and found to be negative – and will be subject to two weeks’ mandatory quarantine in Sydney after they land.However, many Australians still stuck in Peru could not afford the $5,000 being asked for an economy class seat on the flight or missed out on booking, while others are in remote parts of the locked-down country where internal movement is heavily restricted, putting airports out of reach. About 160 Australians remain in Peru.Several New Zealand citizens who were on the flight manifest were taken off it because the Australian government would not allow NZ citizens to transit through Australia to get home.An open letter written by Australian Gus Higgins – who remains in Peru – on behalf of the group has pleaded with the Australian government to launch government-sponsored repatriation flights. “We have watched other governments act. We see foreigners leave each day through the repatriation efforts of their respective governments. Despite being told we are a ‘top priority’, honestly, honourable prime minister, we certainly do not feel so.” Stranded on cruise shipsCruise liners remain a significant challenge to countries worldwide. More than 130 Australians are stranded onboard the coronavirus-stricken ship the Zaandam, which is off the coast of Panama and unsure where it will be allowed to dock. The number of people with flu-like symptoms onboard has risen by almost a third in two days from 139 to 179.Holland America Line, which runs the Zaandam, confirmed there had been no further deaths onboard after four elderly passengers died this week. The causes of death have not been released.The Zaandam and its sister ship the Rotterdam, which sailed to resupply the stricken liner, are preparing to pass through the Panama canal after the country reversed a decision to stop the vessels from crossing.Hundreds of asymptomatic passengers were moved to the Rotterdam over the weekend. None have yet presented with flu-like symptoms. It remains unclear whether the two boats would be allowed to dock in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, after local authorities raised concerns about the health risks the crew and passengers posed to the population. The Fort Lauderdale mayor, Dean Trantalis, has called for US president Donald Trump to intervene and suggested the vessels should be redirected to nearby navy bases.A total of 134 Australians are onboard the MV Ocean Atlantic, currently moored at Montevideo. A commercial charter was being organised to bring those passengers home, but when another Australian cruise ship, the MV Greg Mortimer, was refused entry to Montevideo’s port, the price for that charter flight almost doubled.Those stranded aboard have pleaded for government intervention in an open letter to Scott Morrison: “Prime minister, we need you to act quickly as we do not know how long we will be allowed to stay moored at Montevideo and we don’t know what will happen to us after that.”Late on Monday, foreign minister Marise Payne said the government would assist with the increased ticket price. “The government will ensure the passengers are reimbursed for this price rise,” she said in a statement.

  • 6 from Telangana Who Attended Congregation in Delhi's Nizamuddin Die of Coronavirus
    News
    News18

    6 from Telangana Who Attended Congregation in Delhi's Nizamuddin Die of Coronavirus

    The Telangana Chief Minister's Office (CMO) said the deceased were undergoing treatment at different hospitals in the state after their samples tested positive for the virus.

  • Despite COVID-19 Lockdown MG Motor Sold 1,518 Units in March, More than February
    News
    News18

    Despite COVID-19 Lockdown MG Motor Sold 1,518 Units in March, More than February

    The leading carmaker also announced a Rs 2 crore grant towards procuring gloves, masks, medicines, ventilators, and beds in view of the coronavirus pandemic.

  • Stranded in Uttarakhand: ‘6-7 people in a room… where is social distancing?’
    News
    The Indian Express

    Stranded in Uttarakhand: ‘6-7 people in a room… where is social distancing?’

    The lockdown was imposed in Uttarakhand immediately after the Janata Curfew in the state on March 22.