Can You Smell the Music?

An obsessed duo creates new perfumes to match Indian classical raagas.

The Rushit Raaga Collection. (Photo Credit - Swapnil Sonawane & Sopan Sharma)

To be honest, I had a tinge of cynicism as I read the snippet in a local Marathi daily about the launch of this new product. These are times when brands are built on the crutches of other, already more accomplished brands - when sportsters help sell cars and perfumes carry the names of film stars. Besides, there are few brands as bankable as classical traditions. An inquiry seemed due.

The Rushit Raaga Collection of nine attars (perfumed essential oils) was launched in December at the Savai Gandharva Mahotsav in Pune. One of India's premier congregations of Indian classical music, the Mahotsav is held on the Ramanbaug School grounds in the heart of Peshwa's Pune. It's seen as a place of pride for invited performers and as an institution of gentle smugness for Punekars. These nine attars were launched at a stall at the festival because each scent had been especially designed to match a classical raaga; each attar carries the name of the respective raaga and is priced at Rs 100 per vial.

The collection is an exploration of the possibility that the resonance of a raaga recital can be reflected within the unraveling layers of traditional Indian perfume, attar. The nine attars are: Lalit, Bahaar, Multani, Sarang, Darbaari, Chandrakauns, Marubihag, Bilawal and Hansadhwani. Each has a unique bouquet: the Bahaar attar is thickly floral while Multani is spicy and intense.

These fascinating objects were designed jointly by a professor of mechanical engineering and a merchant navy officer, who chanced upon each other at the Savai festival in 2012. "I have a habit of offering to apply my attars to everyone around me at a mehfil," says Dr Mandar Lele. Anand Jog, who happened to be sitting next to him, was delightfully surprised at the offer. In turn, Jog promised to get his own perfumed creations for Dr. Lele the next day, and they became friends. A few metres from the banks of the Mula-Mutha - the river confluence that makes Pune the city of bridges - these two explorers of music and scent, of raagdaari and attar, began their journey of building a bridge across their twin obsessions.

A PhD in cryogenics from IIT Mumbai, Dr Lele, 43, has had an illustrious career in technical teaching at the Maharashtra Institute of Technology (MIT) in Pune. He used to play the tabla actively and remains obsessed with classical music - he now has a 27-year-long unbroken streak of attending the Savai festivals. Never fond of spray perfumes, Dr Lele has also been passionate about traditional attars since his youth.

"The trees in my garden have begun to grow towards my house," smiles 31-year-old Jog. "I'd like to believe this is because of the raagas that play inside all day." He serves as a merchant navy officer one half of the year when he's often away in foreign waters for long stretches, and spends the rest of his time as a part-time performing flautist and keen perfume-adventurer. Jog inherited his love for perfumes at a young age from his grandfather. His passion blossomed after high school, when he found himself immersed in perfumery books that also gave him an international perspective.

Both men were already engaged in making their own attars and mixes when they met. As the two began to exchange old private recordings of the pandits and ustads of Indian classical music, they also began to test each other's tastes in perfumes by swapping notes on aromatic compounds. And since the impact of both, an intense raaga and a fragrant attar, can last for days, it was only a matter of time before the duo stopped being able to tell one from another. "Our partnership involves a fair bit of mind-reading. We [often] come up with the same ideas at the same time," says Dr Lele of their mutual attunement.
Dr Mandar Lele and Anand Jog. (Photo Credit - Swapnil Sonawane & Sopan Sharma)

In their original Vedic forms, both scent and sound had purposes ranging from healing to spirituality. The popular sheen they received in the last few centuries also added angles of expression, emotion, and entertainment to both forms. Creators began to look at the range of cognitive responses their creations were capable of inciting. Craftsmen turned into artists, and there was a decided proliferation in the fields of both raagas and attars. Many contemporary doyens of classical music have had a deep and connected interest in attars. The likes of Ustad Rashid Khan, Ustad Shahid Parvez and Pt. Ajoy Chakraborty are all known to have armoires stocked with rich, rare and emotionally potent attars, collections of which they pursue with pride.

The two forms of sound and smell have co-existed for centuries, have lived in the same vicinity, and even attended the same schools. For a mind sensitive to these sensations, there certainly was common ground between the two forms. Could this common background provide that critical bit of relevance to go ahead with the attempt to mix the two? Can one make a scent feel like music?

Think Before You Smell

Jog insists that the Rushit Raaga Collection was an experiment, an exploration of a possibility. "There is no question of us claiming that we have decidedly captured the essence of the raagas in our creations - that is silly. All we tried to do was create the attars in such a way that it left us, as individuals, with feelings similar to those that a rendition of the raaga incites within us," he says.

Before they set off on this journey, the duo needed to find some commonality in the two forms to be able to set a course for their creation. The path was found in the form of an interesting, almost human aspect that both a perfume and a raaga share. Some call it persona.

"When we see someone, we often wonder what his voice would be like, his attitude, his vibe," explains Jog. "How his presence makes us feel. In short, his personality. And if you look closely, everything has a personality. Even a raaga." The concept of looking at a raaga as a living, breathing entity has a lot to do with how it is able to connect with people's emotions. Raagas have traditionally been bestowed with their own seasons, their own ideal time of day for flowering, their own colours, even their own objective visuals as depicted through Raagmala paintings. The point has invariably been to create or facilitate emotions that tend towards the ones that listeners feel during and after a mehfil - by attempting to bring out the personality of the raaga.

Perfumes have also been connected with the idea of persona since time immemorial. In fact, most good perfumes are designed with fixed briefs about the sort of persona they are to exude and enhance within the wearer. Just that fact - that one 'wears' a perfume and does not merely apply it - hints at the fact that one's scent is as much a part of the person's character as her or his clothes.

The starting point, then, was to find the persona of a raaga. Nine, actually.

Hard Work Plus Fumes

One may look at the experiment as an exercise in translation, in picking the message of one medium and transmuting it into another. Which also implies that both languages involved in the translation should be understood in entirety by the interpreters. That's exactly where Dr Lele and Jog began, even before the long and arduous process of mixing and remixing ingredients got underway.

"We [first] focused on hearing much more of the raagas we wanted to model the attars on. Lots of recordings from different artists, since every artist tends to shine his or her own unique light on the same raaga," says Jog. The effort was to understand the character of each raaga as holistically as possible, relying on the deep sensitivity, imagination and expression of stalwarts such as Kumar Gandharva and Pt. Bhimsen Joshi, amongst many. Artistes who wrote new raagas just so the emotion in a traditional bandish could be brought out in a more wholesome, human form.

Once the duo were fairly sure that they had got a grip on the emotional effects a particular raaga had on them, the process of creating its matching attar began.

An attar is a complex object, much like a raaga. A product of distillation and combination, the starting ingredients for an attar are essential oils gleaned from nature - roots, shoots, flowers, leaves, even glandular secretions when it comes to something like musk. After fixing the essential oil base for an attar, you add the notes of perfume - ingredients, each with their own note and character, that find their way on top of the base oil. Floral essences extracted from aromatic flowers such as rose, champa and chameli often come into the picture at this stage. Hina, itself a traditional mixture of more than 40 different herbs, is also used as a key ingredient to great effect.

To extract the essential oils through distillation, they had to first be dissolved in bases appropriate for this particular experiment - ranging from water and oil, and sparingly, alcohol - in order to stay as close as possible to the traditional method of attar-making. Since cost was a critical question, a rare and costly element like sandalwood oil (widely used as a base in traditional attars) had to be substituted with chemically synthesized alternatives that managed to approximate the same effect. Binding agents (the bases in which the concentrated essences are diluted and suspended) also play a major role in the character of the attar and had to be chosen just as carefully.

But just getting the ingredients in place was far from an accomplishment. Much like a raaga, where the variation and interplay of the same twelve notes in relation to one another creates drastically different emotional resonances, the placement of the perfumed ingredients within an attar and the manner in which they interact with each other changes the character of the perfume as a whole beyond recognition.

The only way to get this equation right is through trial and error. Since the emotional goal for each perfume was clear and fixed, based on the duo's extensive hearing sessions, the task was made more effective but no less time consuming. "The only thing we stayed true to was how the creations were making us feel, and if those feelings were commensurate with our emotions about the raaga" Dr Lele points out. The process extended for weeks, sometimes months for some particularly demanding raagas.

Raaga Bahaar proved the toughest and took the longest time to develop. It is a unique raaga that isn't performed frequently as a pure raaga and has no particular time of the day or year to use as a guideline. The quickest attars turned out to be Multani and Chandrakauns since those raagas have strong, defining emotional characteristics that lend themselves to fragrances quite effectively.

There remained technical issues, not just chemical but also musical. How does one recreate the emotional appeal of the interplay of the two nishads in Raaga Malhaar? Or the two chromatic madhyams of Raaga Lalit? These notes are milestones in the character of these raagas and certainly can't be ignored if one wishes to capture the essence of their mood. Dr Lele and Jog's solution, once again, was to not get caught in the technicalities of the medium but to attempt to reach the core of what the raagas stood for in spirit.

Thus, Raaga Lalit's morning call was given, in attar form, the fresh, almost devotional quality associated with the start of the day - two fresh and meditative fragrances of sandal and rose that are different in spirit, used to mimic the two chromatic madhyams of the raaga.

Raaga Hansadhwani is a sweet evening raaga that corresponded to a fresh, happy scent of vanillin, lavender and some fruity tones to secrete 'happy' rasas. Raaga Multani is an evening melody with a teevra madhyam (sharp fourth note), which meant an intense and introspective scent - its attar has sharp and spicy overtones. Raaga Bahaar is a festive raaga that represents the spring season, and so its attar has different floral, fruity and citrus notes alongside bergamot.

As they progressed, further grounds of commonality began to reveal themselves - not just between the effects of the two sensory experiences but also within the way these effects are created. A khayal performance begins with the aalaap that grabs the attention of listeners, moves into the bandish in a low tempo which creates the real character of the performer's interpretation of the raaga, and ends with a fast-paced taan play that listeners carry back home in their heads. In the olfactory construction of a perfume, there are three notes that work to approximately the same effect - the quickly dissipating top note that announces an entry, the middle note that forms the true essence of the perfume, and the bottom note that is known to linger on for days.

Scents & Sounds

Connoisseurs at the Savai festival who sampled the Rushit Raaga attars seemed to agree that the effort had been successful. Many were able to identify, with uncanny accuracy, the raagas the attars were based on. Dr Lele and Jog also found others working on similar lines: "My Bahaar didn't turn out to be this nice!" one visitor to their stall claimed. Many came back after the first day to congratulate them on their work.

While it wasn't a commercial effort but more to check if the experiment worked, the pair says they ended up selling around 2,500 bottles at the festival. Their website has some details about the collection and they plan to set up an online portal to help connoisseurs place orders.

The duo had originally planned to create 10 attars based on the raagas that appealed to them. The final one, based on Raaga Basant, with a saffron tinge and the freshness of spring, never resolved to their liking despite four months of rigorous trial and error. So they decided to let it be.

This lack of a sense of agency, of letting things be, is what sets their endeavor apart. "[Aside from] the efforts that we put in, we do believe that we have not created these scents. They have gotten created through us," Dr Lele says. "We are merely the mediums."

Sopan Sharma spent five years pushing pen and car tin at ZigWheels. He is now a media entrepreneur and freelance writer based in Pune.


  • Everyone has their Pashto cinema storyTue 12 May, 2015

    But only some of us have the deep reserves of courage to tell that story

  • Kushinagar: The place where Buddha diedTue 5 May, 2015

    The town in Uttar Pradesh where the Buddha died is of great significance, but remains relatively unknown. A new graphic book recounts a journey to the historical sites associated with the life of the Buddha, and how in the midst of India’s spiritual collisions the author came face to face with his mortality in Kushinagar.

  • Who decides how much my Crocin will cost?Mon 4 May, 2015

    A month ago, the government raised the price of 500-odd essential drugs by 3.84 percent. Is it a fair rise, and does it ultimately benefit the consumer? Is controlling the prices of all drugs sold in India – which the government is considering – a good plan? A manufacturer of low-cost drugs explains.

  • You’d probably make more money in a fixed deposit than a news channelWed 29 Apr, 2015

    Wait. No one watches the news? Then why are there so many news channels. The writer of a new book on the industry explains the real reason these channels are launched.

  • How Reliable is the World’s Most Influential Business Consultant?Mon 27 Apr, 2015

    Ram Charan has worked ascetically for almost half a century consulting with top CEOs and businesses across the world. He claims to live in planes and hotels and own a house only for tax reasons. But as a writer of case studies, Charan has left the historical record poorer without a sense of how businesses deal with corruption and politics. His public analyses are usually simplistic, reducing complex corporate stories to tales of thrilling heroes who succeeded because they did something.

  • The Extraordinary Network Across India That’s Helping Restore Our Film Heritage, One Trashed Reel At A TimeFri 24 Apr, 2015

    From Alam Ara to Black Friday, from Paanch to Thalapathi, the list of Indian films whose prints have been lost is long. Not only have we lost almost 80 percent of our films made before 1964, we continue to lose recent ones too. But there are some extraordinary efforts now underway to hunt and restore these films, some of which involve the very people who used to destroy these prints for profit.

  • How I Began to ReadWed 22 Apr, 2015

    My discovery of reading and the books that inspired me

  • Your Handy-Dandy Guide to the Bihar Assembly ElectionsMon 20 Apr, 2015

    Bihar will see Assembly elections before the end of November this year. But the games will begin long before that. Who are the key players? What are the cool moves? Our writer digs through perception and realpolitik to bring you this primer to the upcoming tournament.

  • Good People and Bad People Meet in ShimlaFri 17 Apr, 2015

    The UK television show ‘Indian Summers’, set in the 1930s Raj summer capital of Shimla, has been Channel 4's most expensive drama ever. As it concludes its finale this weekend and readies for a second season, will it go beyond an understanding of the British Empire as largely a case of bad manners and political incorrectness?

  • Are Farmers Going to Be Modi’s Biggest Blind Spot?Wed 15 Apr, 2015

    Narendra Modi declares his commitment to farmers all the time but his government has steadily acted against them. The political cost is going to be steep. From rail rokos and stone-pelting to urea trucks being looted, farmers across the country are increasingly ranged against the NDA government.

  • Three Supreme Court Orders Later, What's the Deal with Aadhaar?Mon 13 Apr, 2015

    By law, you should not be denied any government service in India if you don’t have an Aadhar card number. So why do various government programs continue to ignore three Supreme Court orders and insist on the dreaded number, and how are they getting away with it?

  • Five problems ailing veterinary medicine in India that you should know aboutFri 10 Apr, 2015

    Besides our attachment to pet animals,India’s livestock industry alone contributes almost four percent of the GDP. So why does veterinary medicine in India languish with perennial problems?

  • The Slave Ship that Ran from Kerala to New OrleansWed 8 Apr, 2015

    Post Hurricane Katrina, a whole new American dream was designed for some Indians — how to get trapped in a guarded labor camp by an American company. Five of these Indians just won $14 million in damages in their fight for justice and dignity, in one of the largest labor trafficking cases in US history. There are more than 200 other plaintiffs awaiting justice in this explosive, racist example of how America's broken visa program continues to exploit international migrants.

  • Why Spanish Is On Its Way to Becoming One of India’s Favoured Foreign LanguagesMon 6 Apr, 2015

    The New Delhi branch of the Instituto Cervantes had the highest number of enrollments in the world in 2014. In Anantapur, Andhra Pradesh, young people are betting on Spanish for their big city dreams. What’s going on with desi learners of Espanol?

  • Hello? Anyone seen my swine flu mutation?Thu 2 Apr, 2015

    An MIT study says the swine flu sweeping India might be a deadly new mutation. The National Institute of Virology in Pune firmly disputes this. How can there be such a vast difference of opinion? Could both be right or both be wrong? Is there a scientific conspiracy, a cover up, a screw up or something else entirely? We sought an independent scientific analysis and, as the Internet phrase goes, our conclusions may surprise you.

  • Does Kerala need a share of the Rs 200 crore Naxal pie?Mon 30 Mar, 2015

    This month the Kerala Home Minister approached the Union government to declare three districts from the state as Naxal-affected. But does the state have a Naxal problem and who would it benefit to have it declared so?

  • That Thing About Creating NalandasFri 27 Mar, 2015

    If India were to have one library for every 3,000 people it would need around 4,23,333 libraries. It is estimated that India has 54,856 libraries. A recent national conference talked of ways to fix this, but are numbers all that we are falling short on?

  • How to Go From Boyish to ByomkeshWed 25 Mar, 2015

    Sushant Singh Rajput and the man behind the star. And how Dibakar Banerjee moulded him into the beloved everyman detective, Byomkesh Bakshy.

  • What is terrorizing Marathwada’s farmers?Mon 23 Mar, 2015

    The hailstorm and unseasonal rains in 2014 that destroyed the rabi crop were thought to be freak events until they happened again this year, spurring fears of a sharp rise in the number of farmer suicides, bidding to outrun Vidarbha in its tragic scale. Is the weather the sole cause of Marathwada’s agrarian crisis, and how can this crisis be tackled?

  • Can a Counterculture Become an Ethical Industry?Fri 20 Mar, 2015

    These days several Indian cities are enlivened by splashes of color: an imaginative mural, a stylish tag, a critical stencil. Street art and graffiti seem to be sprouting everywhere, but there is growing skepticism in the community on what it means when our consumer culture starts patronizing this usually unsanctioned art form.

  • Is the AAP Crumbling? Again?Wed 18 Mar, 2015

    Despite its incredible win in the Delhi polls, the party’s implosion started a while ago. A look at how all the infighting and backbiting has been steadily coming to a boil.

  • When I Die, I Want A PartyMon 16 Mar, 2015

    In June 2013, the writer met Suzette Jordan a week after she’d decided she would no longer be stifled by the name, ‘The Park Street Rape Victim’ and all that it implied. And there began a quiet friendship. This week, shaken by the news of Jordan’s sudden death, the writer attends the funeral and joins the family in remembering this extraordinary woman.

  • Things I learned at the Asian Women’s FestivalFri 13 Mar, 2015

    The International Association of Women in Radio and Television held its Asian Women’s Film Festival again this year, showcasing the work of women, but not necessarily about women. Here’s what our writer found.

  • Everything you need to know at the legal end of the Masarat Alam controversyTue 10 Mar, 2015

    And what's with Jammu & Kashmir’s Public Safety Act?