Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    The Water Cooler

    The Price of Rape: Rs 42

    According to the Planning Commission, human dignity is worth Rs 2 lakh. That's the maximum compensation for a rape victim who files an FIR with enough evidence and pursues the correct legal channels. The price of a life is higher. A minor or mentally challenged woman, or a woman who gets pregnant or contracts AIDS as a result of the rape, might claim the princely sum of Rs. 3 lakh.

    January 2, 2012, the Delhi court awarded compensation of Rs 1 lakh to a 17-year-old rape victim awaiting justice. She was 14 when the incident occurred. In the interim, she tried to kill herself by consuming acid, and was reduced to a vegetative existence. The court, appropriately 'shocked' with the situation, coughed up a lakh and sent her back to the queue.

    Article 38 (1) of the Constitution of India provides for Criminal Injuries Compensation Boards in every state. The Supreme Court has ruled in favor of setting up the boards. The National Women's Commission, the Working Women's Commission, and several legal associations have spoken about probable benefits. To date, the board exists only on mildewed official papers.

    Our budget policies are ruled by the 11th Five Year Plan (2007 — 2012) that mentions a certain 'Scheme for Relief and Rehabilitation of Rape Victims' drafted by the National Women's Commission. This scheme would help rape victims lodge instant FIRs and claim compensation, help build forensic labs for DNA testing, "sensitize law enforcement agencies, medical establishments", etc.

    Now for the reality check. In the Budget of 2009-10, the amount set aside for relief of rape victims was Rs 53.3 crore. In 2010-11 this was reduced to Rs 36.2 crore, and to Rs 7.5 crore in 2011-12, i.e. less by 85%. Obviously, spending state money on raped women was not a government priority. It gets worse on looking closer. Out of the horde set aside in 2009-10, only Rs 9 lakh was actually spent. According to a study by the Centre for Enquiry into Health and Allied Themes, that's Rs 42 per victim.

    Records show the same promises of compensation surfacing after each public litigation and infamous case of rape since 2009. Each time, the declaration sounds like the first decisive step taken by a 'shocked' government that has just woken up to the financial and medical needs of rape victims. Let's sit back, tune in, and enjoy the repeat shows.

     

    42 comments

    • EQUALISER  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      A woman's dignity is not Rs 42. A woman who is a child (daughter) grows up to be a teenager and later becomes a wife, then a mother, then a mother-in-law, or a grand mother and finally some become great grandmothers. Why can't our society give her due respects and protect her? All rivers (at least most) are named after women, Goddess of wealth is Laxmi, Goddess of courage is Dhurga etc and etc. Let her be ANY caste. Please respect her.
    • Saurabh  •  Patna, Bihar  •  3 months ago
      problem of rape will not be solved until the culprit is socially ostracized and sentenced to death. There is no human right of a rapist and he must be castrated and then hanged till death.
      • DILIP Dombivalikar 3 months ago
        Saurabh,I agree with you.Should law be helpless,public should make justice themself !
      • Shubha 2 months ago
        Yes. The Law and Order is helpless to take stringent action against such heinous criminals as political and other in Position elements, interfere in this and pour water, on some rightful and strict Law and Order personal and resist them to do their duty. This is natural in a democratic administration. In some States, 'desperate' criminals, pour acid on girls and in some cases, some use weapons to slit throat of girls. Oh Justice where are you? G.S.Kumar, Hyderabad
    • nani  •  Chennai, Tamil Nadu  •  3 months ago
      shameful act.. shocked to know that human dignity is worth Rs.42/-
    • sanjay  •  Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh  •  3 months ago
      So called Women Organisations like NCW etc have reduced to ornamental in nature. their occupants don't know what and how to demand from govt.and fight for women's rights. They just enjoy the priveleges available to the post and only in handful of cases which is highlighted by media they pretend to act. So many rapes, acid attacks, dowry killings are being committed in the country and these fellows who have the resposibility for acting on behalf of the sufferers and ensure proper justice is rendered to them, are just relaxing and devoting more time in doing inaugrations, delivering lectures on women empowerment. Shame, Shame!
    • Vishal  •  Mumbai, Maharashtra  •  3 months ago
      Dignity cannot be priced, 42rs or 42 billion rs
    • Jagdish Chandra  •  Ajmer, Rajasthan  •  3 months ago
      its shamful.
    • hizibiz  •  Sunnyvale, United States  •  3 months ago
      Is that disconnected from other areas of social justice and responsibilities the Govt. is withdrawing from ? I don't think so . Acceptance of Washington consensus dictates Govt. to move away from its social responsibilites more and more . Let the market 'fix' it :)
    • Aleen Khan  •  Pune, Maharashtra  •  2 months ago
      What the hell WOMAN COMMISSION doing for this?
    • Yogin Koppikar  •  Bangalore, Karnataka  •  2 months ago
      Budget allocations made are essentially extra pockets kept in readiness to make money later. No wonder the study by the Centre for Enquiry into Health and Allied Themes points out that the average compensation paid by the government to rape victims Rs 42 per victim. You see the ministers who decide on the budget allocation and spending need to first think of their own welfare, followed by their parties' welfare and last the common rape victims if some money remains. And we have the government babus waiting for the kill. A hopeless state of corruption, lawlessness and highhandedness for all the rape victims. The compensation needs to be exemplary and not a paltry 1 to 3 lakh when the court intervenes and gives a ruling. The raped individual needs to go through a torture of detestable cross-examinations and the risk of being raped again by the powers to be and the police. Ho wonder rape incidents are hushed up voluntarily by the victims and their families.
    • subhendu  •  2 months ago
      It is only our comercial mentality tries to compensate a rape victim through monetary compansation just like comercial enjoyment of sex. Every body think that they have done justice to the victim.We never try to reduce the stigma attached to the victim and the status displacementin the society Society/ psychologist should do something in this regard to restore dignity of the victim which will be the real compensation.
    • DILIP Dombivalikar  •  Kalyan Dombivli, Maharashtra  •  3 months ago
      There can not be any amount of money ,that can compensate the hurt.Rs.42 is mockry .All involved in ,related dicision making process should be removed from their authority/job ,for this foul thinking.In my opinion ,the rapist should be KILLED in open ,Husband,brother,father ,friend,lover or who ever be the male member in the family should do this,within one year of the instance,and law should allow them to do that
    • debendra  •  New Delhi, Delhi  •  3 months ago
      Only present incumbent of Planning Commission can evaluate like this.It should be a national shame.
    • MANISH  •  Gurgaon, Haryana  •  3 months ago
      Oh.... This is really rally sad that a human dignity's worth is 2 lakh. Even I can not beleve that in India here is no worth of Humanity
    • Gaurav Das  •  Bhubaneswar, Orissa  •  3 months ago
      It shows that still a value of human life is less than the value of hawai chappal,which cost more than the life of a human,this can only happen in India our INCREDIBLE INDIA
    • Prakash  •  New Delhi, Delhi  •  3 months ago
      this may interested you
    • PANDI  •  Bangalore, Karnataka  •  3 months ago
      THE PLANNING COMMISSION IS FULLO OF FOOLS
    • Shiva Prakash  •  Sewaie, Uttar Pradesh  •  3 months ago
      Extremely shocked to know about Rs.42/- for a rape victim.The existing laws and goernment's efforts to bring quick justice to the victim and punishment to the perpetrator of the crime are shockingly inadequate.The budget allottment by the goverment for relief measures to such victims hsa dwindled to a paultry amount in last few years.The people's apathy to such an important social issue is also to be vehemetly criticised .
    • Siva Rama Krishna  •  Mumbai, Maharashtra  •  3 months ago
      in today's world, people want culture and tradition and at the same time they want freedom enjoyment etc. these two things go opposite. it is these women organizations that question...why women should not have freedom, why cant they be independent etc. it is these arguments that lead to rapes in any society. after getting raped....the same organizations cry foul. every woman has to be protected by father, husband and son. this is because women lose their freedom by their own activities.
      • Rahul 3 months ago
        i am not completely agree with you...i believe every woman should be protected by her husband/father etc..,but they have their own life too,they have equal right for freedom.so it is not their fault,it is fault of man who rapes...
      • DILIP Dombivalikar 3 months ago
        Siva,I understand what you mean.Most of the working women in cities work for pleasure,like sarees,hotelling,second home etc.Where as man work mainly for supporting basic needs of the family.Working women ,exposed themself to all sort of human tendancies,and chances of falling pray to them increases when they are out and alone,unless they are physciaclly,emotionally fit to fight.And question is ,do we have any training schools doing this ?Women can be made fools/can be cheated very easily ( you may refer any news paper for that )-that is the general understanding ,and rapiest take advantage of this.Women should be given freedom -but in safe areas.Women organisation ,should not make women to fight and win against men .,and accept the natural limitations.
    • Gaurav Das  •  Bhubaneswar, Orissa  •  3 months ago
      this shows still the valu of women in india is less than a value of hawai chappal which cost more than that,its a shame and a slap on we Indians.Some say India is a great country,here is the greatness showed.
    • rahul  •  Faridabad, Haryana  •  3 months ago
      we 've collectively failed as a nation and being human.

    Columnist Profiles

    Follow Us on Facebook

    Blogs